top of page

Publications

​ManyBirds Study 1 (MB1) - Paper 1

A large-scale study across the avian clade identifies ecological drivers of neophobia

Abstract: Neophobia, or aversion to novelty, is important for adaptability and survival as it influences the ways in which animals navigate risk and interact with their environments. Across individuals, species and other taxonomic levels, neophobia is known to vary considerably, but our understanding of the wider ecological drivers of neophobia is hampered by a lack of comparative multispecies studies using standardized methods. Here, we utilized the ManyBirds Project, a Big Team Science large-scale collaborative open science framework, to pool efforts and resources of 129 collaborators at 77 institutions from 24 countries worldwide across six continents. We examined both difference scores (between novel object test and control conditions) and raw data of latency to touch familiar food in the presence (test) and absence (control) of a novel object among 1,439 subjects from 136 bird species across 25 taxonomic orders incorporating lab, field, and zoo sites. We first demonstrated that consistent differences in neophobia existed among individuals, among species, and among other taxonomic levels in our dataset, rejecting the null hypothesis that neophobia is highly plastic at all taxonomic levels with no evidence for evolutionary divergence. We then tested for effects of ecological factors on neophobia, including diet, sociality, habitat, and range, while accounting for phylogeny. We found that (i) species with more specialist diets were more neophobic than those with more generalist diets, providing support for the Neophobia Threshold Hypothesis; (ii) migratory species were also more neophobic than nonmigratory species, which supports the Dangerous Niche Hypothesis. Our study shows that the evolution of avian neophobia has been shaped by ecological drivers and demonstrates the potential of Big Team Science to advance our understanding of animal behavior.

​

MB1 Collaborators: Link to Google Doc

​

Example experimental videos: Link to YouTube

Screenshot 2026-10-14 at 17.30.27.png

MB1 Collaborators (listed alphabetically)

  • Benjamin J. Ashton (Flinders University, Australia)

  • Alice M.I. Auersperg (University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Solenne Belle (Univ Montpellier, France)

  • Boris Bilčík (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Laura M. Biondi (Universidad Nacional de Mar del Plata, Argentina)

  • Francesco Bonadonna (Univ Montpellier, France)

  • Desiree Brucks (University of Giessen, Germany) 

  • Michael W. Butler (Lafayette College, USA)

  • Samuel P. Caro (Univ Montpellier, France)

  • Kai R. Caspar (Czech University of Life Sciences, Czech Republic)

  • Marion Charrier (Univ Rennes, France)

  • Tiffany Chatelin (Univ Rennes, France)

  • Johnathan Ching (Pacific University, USA)

  • Nicola S. Clayton (University of Cambridge, UK)

  • Benjamin J. Cluver (Lafayette College, USA)

  • Ella Cochran (Louisiana State University, USA)

  • Francesca Cornero (University of Cambridge, UK)

  • Emily Danby (Cambridge, Cambridge, UK)

  • Samara Danel (University of Rochester, USA)

  • Martina Darwich (Austrian Academy of Sciences, Austria)

  • James R. Davies (University of Cambridge, UK)

  • Aliciade la Colina (Fundación Temaikèn, Escobar,Argentina)

  • Dominik Fischer (Zoo Wuppertal, Germany)

  • Ondřej Fišer (University of South Bohemia, Czech Republic)

  • Florencia Foitzick (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Edward C. Galluccio (University of Western Australia, Australia)

  • Clara Garcia-Co (Antwerp University, Belgium)

  • Elias Garcia-Pelegrin (National University of Singapore, Singapore)

  • Isabelle George (Univ Rennes, France)

  • Kai-Philipp Gladow (Bielefeld University, Germany)

  • Raúl O. Gómez (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Anna Grewer (Zoo Krefeld gGmbH, Germany)

  • Katie Grice (University College Cork, Ireland)

  • Lauren M. Guillette (University of Alberta, Canada)

  • Devon C. Hallihan (Lafayette College, USA)

  • Katie J. Harrington (University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Frauke Heer (Zoo Wuppertal, Germany)

  • Chloe Henry (Univ Rennes, France)

  • Vladimira Hodova (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Marisa Hoeschele (Austrian Academy of Sciences, Austria)

  • Cécilia Houdelier (Univ Rennes, France)

  • Paula Ibáñez de Aldecoa (University of Vienna, Austria)

  • Oluwaseun S. Iyasere (University of Agriculture, Nigeria)

  • Yuka Kanemitsu (Hokkaido University, Japan)

  • Mina Khodadad (Ruhr University Bochum, Germany)

  • Duc Khong (Pacific University, USA)

  • Melanie G. Kimball (Louisiana State University, USA)

  • Ariana N. Klappert (Universiy of Bonn, Germany)

  • Lucy N. Koch (University Vienna, Austria)

  • Uta U. König (University of Giessen, Germany)

  • Ľubor Košťál (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Anastasia Krasheninnikova (Max-Planck-Institute for Biological Intelligence, Germany)​

  • Lubica Kubikova (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Megan L. Lambert (University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Connor T. Lambert (University of Alberta, Canada)

  • Daan W. Laméris (Antwerp University, Belgium)

  • Courtenay G. Lampert (Lafayette College, USA)

  • Oceane Larousse (Université Paris-Saclay, France)

  • Christine R. Lattin (Louisiana State University, USA)

  • Zhongqiu Li (Nanjing University, China)

  • Michael Lindenmeier (Museum Koenig Bonn, Germany)

  • Delia A. Lister (Pittsburg State University, USA)

  • Jimena Lois-Milevicich (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Julia A. Mackenzie (Anglia Ruskin University, UK)

  • Selina Mainz (University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany)

  • Danna Masri (Louisiana State University, USA)

  • Jorg J. M. Massen (Utrecht University, Netherlands)

  • Claudia Mettke-Hofmann (Liverpool John Moores University, UK)

  • Rachael Miller (Harrison) (University of Exeter, UK)

  • Laurenz Mohr (University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany)

  • Wendt Müller (Antwerp University, Belgium)

  • Paul M. Nealen (University of Pennsylvania, USA)

  • Andreas Nieder (University of Tuebingen, USA)

  • Aurèle Novac (University of Neuchatel, Switzerland)

  • Nínive Paes Cavalcante (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Carla Pascual-Guàrdia (University of Neuchâtel, Switzerland)

  • Ayushi Patel (Louisiana State University. USA)

  • Katarína Pichová (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Cristina Pilenga (Zoomarine Italia, Italy)

  • Laurent Prétôt (Pittsburg State University, USA)

  • John Quinn (University College Cork, Ireland)

  • Elena Račevska (Algebra University, Croatia)

  • Stephan A. Reber (Lund University, Sweden)

  • Juan C. Reboreda (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Sam Reynolds (Anglia Ruskin University, UK)

  • Amanda R. Ridley (University of Western Australia, Australia)

  • Theresa Rössler (Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Francisco Ruiz-Raya (University of Glasgow, UK)

  • Marina Salas (Royal Zoological Society of Antwerp, Belgium)

  • Beatriz C. Saldanha (Universidade do Porto, Portugal)

  • Sebastián M. Santiago (Universidad de Buenos Aires, Argentina)

  • Nikola Schlöglová (University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Gia Seatriz (Pacific University, USA)

  • Eva Serrano-Davies (Netherlands Institute of Ecology, Netherlands)​

  • Eva G. Shair Ali (University of Veterinary Medicine Vienna, Austria)

  • Janja Sirovnik (University of Veterinary Medicine, Austria)

  • Zuzana Skalná (Slovak Academy of Sciences, Slovakia)

  • Vedrana Šlipogor (Lausanne University Hospital, Switzerland)

  • Katie E. Slocombe (University of York, UK)

  • Masayo Soma (Hokkaido University, Japan)

  • Carl D. Soulsbury (University of Lincoln, UK)

  • Tiziana Srdoc (University of Vienna, Austria)

  • Stefan Stanescu (University of Alberta, Canada)

  • Michaela Syrová (University of South Bohemia, Czech Republic)

  • Alex H. Taylor (Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona, Spain)

  • Christopher N. Templeton (Western Washington UniversityBiology, USA)

  • Karlie Thompson (University of Pennsylvania, USA)

  • Sandra Trigo (Universidade do Porto, Portugal)

  • Camille A. Troisi (Ghent University, Belgium)

  • Utku Urhan (Lund University, Sweden)

  • Keesvan Oers (Netherlands Institute of Ecology, Netherlands)

  • Maurice Valbert (Max-Planck Comparative Cognition Research Station, Tenerife)

  • Alberto Velando (Universidade de Vigo, Spain)

  • Frederick Verbruggen (Ghent University, Belgium)

  • Jorrit W. Verkleij (Utrecht University, Netherlands)

  • Alizée Vernouillet (Ghent University, Belgium)

  • Jonas Verspeek (Antwerp University, Belgium)

  • Petr Veselý (University of South Bohemia, Czech Republic)

  • Auguste M. P. von Bayern (Max-Planck-Institute for Biological Intelligence, Tenerife)

  • Eline Waalders (Anglia Ruskin University, UK)

  • Benjamin A. Whittaker (University of Alberta, Canada)

  • Ella R. Williamson (University of York, UK)

  • Vanessa A. D. Wilson (University of Neuchatel, Switzerland)

  • Michelle Winfield (Pacific University. USA)

  • Neslihan Wittek (Ruhr University Bochum, Germany)

  • Karen K. L. Yeung (University of Alberta, Canada)

  • Jade A. Zanutto (Utrecht University, Netherlands)

  • Melissa Bateson (Newcastle University, UK)

  • Kristina Pascual (Newcastle University, UK)

ManyBirds Collaborations

Abstract: Big team science networks are large-scale, collaborative, global initiatives that pool intellectual and material resources to address shared scientific questions while increasing transparency, inclusivity and replicability. In animal cognition and behaviour, these networks, such as ManyPrimates, ManyBirds and ManyDogs, emerged in response to the replicability crisis, overcoming limitations such as small sample sizes, taxonomic biases and restricted species or researcher representation. These networks have produced empirical work, commentaries and reviews demonstrating proof-of-concept for comparative, multi-species research. However, leading such networks, particularly as early-career researchers, presents challenges, including: (1) managing a team (communication, relationship-building, community trust), (2) managing others (navigating power dynamics and challenging behaviour), and (3) managing self (confidence, experience and motivation). Challenge impacts may include delayed research progress, risk of reputational harm and increased stress or burnout, especially for researchers navigating job precarity and career progression. We outline solutions and gains, including transparent governance, authorship criteria, communication strategies and the need for mentorship and leadership training. Sustained funding and active, supportive engagement from others are essential. Ultimately, big team science complements traditional single-lab models, promoting collaboration over competition. Our collective experience suggests that big team science leadership, although it can be high risk, is among the most rewarding, transformative career experiences.

ManyBirds Collaborations

Flexible Behavior or Flexible Methods? A Cross-Taxon Review of Experimental Designs in Reversal Learning

Abstract: Behavioral flexibility—the ability to adapt behavior in response to changing conditions—is commonly measured using reversal learning tasks, where individuals must inhibit a previously rewarded response and adopt a new one after contingencies change. Despite widespread use, task comparability across species remains unclear. We systematically reviewed 206 empirical studies (2014–2023) spanning eight taxa: invertebrates, fishes, amphibians and reptiles, birds, rodents, non-human primates, humans, and other mammals. We extracted species coverage, sampling, learning and reversal criteria, cue types, and outcome measures, and characterized cross-taxon variation using nonparametric tests, correlation analyses, linear discriminant analyses, and model-based robustness checks. We identify three methodological obstacles. First, research is highly imbalanced, concentrated on humans, birds, and rodents. Most animal diversity remains virtually untested, with under 1% of described species represented in five of the seven non-human taxa. Second, research is taxonomically fragmented: 99% of studies examine only one taxon, limiting direct comparisons. Third, methodological standards diverge dramatically across taxa. Humans consistently face the strictest learning criteria, while other taxa typically use lower thresholds. Mean reversal phases differ more than threefold across taxa: single-reversal designs predominate in amphibians and reptiles, fishes, and invertebrates, whereas multi-reversal protocols are relatively more frequent in humans and non-human primates. Sample sizes, evaluation window lengths, cue types, and outcome measures also show taxon-specific patterns. These systematic design differences complicate cross-taxon comparisons, blurring the line between true cognitive variation and methodological artifacts. Greater methodological coordination and broader taxonomic coverage are needed, and emerging large-scale collaborations offer a promising path forward.

ManyBirds Collaborations

Challenges and promises of big team comparative cognition

Abstract: Big team science has the potential to reshape comparative cognition research, but its implementation — especially in making fair comparisons between species, handling multisite variation and reaching researcher consensus — poses daunting challenges. Here, we propose solutions and discuss how big team science can transform the field.

ManyBirds Collaborations

Comparative Cognition Needs Big Team Science: How Large-Scale Collaborations Will Unlock the Future of the Field

Abstract: Comparative cognition research has been largely constrained to isolated facilities, small teams, and a limited number of species. This has led to challenges such as conflicting conceptual definitions and underpowered designs. Here, we explore how Big Team Science (BTS) may remedy these issues. Specifically, we identify and describe four key BTS advantages – increasing sample size and diversity, enhancing task design, advancing theories, and improving welfare and conservation efforts. We conclude that BTS represents a transformative shift capable of advancing research in the field.

ManyBirds Collaborations

ManyBirds: A multi-site collaborative Open Science approach to avian cognition and behavior research

Abstract: Comparative cognitive and behavior research aims to investigate cognitive evolution by comparing performance in different species to understand how these abilities have evolved. Ideally, this requires large and diverse samples; however, these can be difficult to obtain by single labs or institutions, leading to potential reproducibility and generalization issues with small, less representative samples. To help mitigate these issues, we are establishing a multi-site collaborative Open Science approach called ManyBirds, with the aim of providing new insight into the evolution of avian cognition and behavior through large-scale comparative studies, following the lead of exemplary ManyPrimates, ManyBabies and ManyDogs projects. Here, we outline a) the replicability crisis and why we should study birds, including the origin of modern birds, avian brains and convergent evolution of cognition; b) the current state of the avian cognition field, including a ‘snapshot’ review; c) the ManyBirds project, with plans, infrastructure, limitations, implications and future directions. In sharing this process, we hope that this may be useful for other researchers in devising similar projects in other taxa, like non-avian reptiles or mammals, and to encourage further collaborations with ManyBirds and related ManyX projects. Ultimately, we hope to promote collaboration between ManyX projects to allow for wider investigation of the evolution of cognition across all animals, including potentially humans.

ManyBirds Collaborations

Socio-ecological correlates of neophobia in corvids

Abstract: Behavioral responses to novelty, including fear and subsequent avoidance of novel stimuli, i.e., neophobia, determine how animals interact with their environment. Neophobia aids in navigating risk and impacts on adaptability and survival. There is variation within and between individuals and species; however, lack of large-scale, comparative studies critically limits investigation of the socio-ecological drivers of neophobia. In this study, we tested responses to novel objects and food (alongside familiar food) versus a baseline (familiar food alone) in 10 corvid species (241 subjects) across 10 labs worldwide. There were species differences in the latency to touch familiar food in the novel object and novel food conditions relative to the baseline. Four of seven socio-ecological factors influenced object neophobia: (1) use of urban habitat (versus not), (2) territorial pair versus family group sociality, (3) large versus small maximum flock size, and (4) moderate versus specialized caching (whereas range, hunting live animals, and genus did not), while only maximum flock size influenced food neophobia. We found that, overall, individuals were temporally and contextually repeatable (i.e., consistent) in their novelty responses in all conditions, indicating neophobia is a stable behavioral trait. With this study, we have established a network of corvid researchers, demonstrating potential for further collaboration to explore the evolution of cognition in corvids and other bird species. These novel findings enable us, for the first time in corvids, to identify the socio-ecological correlates of neophobia and grant insight into specific elements that drive higher neophobic responses in this avian family group.

Corvid Comparison.avif

ManyBirds Collaborations

Abstract: Animal cognition covers various mental processes including perception, learning, decision‐making and memory, and animal behavior is often used as a proxy for measuring cognition. Animal cognition/behavior research has multiple benefits; it provides fundamental knowledge of animal biology and evolution but can also have applied conservation and welfare applications. Zoos provide an excellent yet relatively untapped resource for animal cognition research, because they house a wide variety of species—many of which are under threat—and allow close observation and relatively high experimental control compared to the wild. Multi‐zoo collaboration leads to increased sample size and species representation, which in turn leads to more robust science. However, there are salient challenges associated with zoo‐ based cognitive research, which are animal‐based (e.g., small sample sizes at single zoos, untrained/unhabituated subjects, side effects) and human‐based (e.g., time restrictions, safety concerns, and perceptions of animals interacting with unnatural technology or apparatus). We aim to increase the understanding and subsequent uptake of animal cognition research in zoos, by transparently outlining the main benefits and challenges. Importantly, we use our own research (1) a study on novelty responses in hornbills, and (2) a multi‐site collaboration called the “ManyBirds” Project to demonstrate how challenges may be overcome. These potential options include using “drop and go” apparatuses that require no training, close human contact or animal separation. This study is aimed at zoo animal care and research staff, as well as external researchers interested in zoo‐based studies.

bottom of page